621 Comments

This is so true. The best explanation of this (in my opinion) is from Marilyn Frye: “To say that straight men are heterosexual is only to say that they engage in sex (f*cking) exclusively with the other sex, i.e., women. All or almost all of that which pertains to love, most straight men reserve exclusively for other men. The people whom they admire, respect, adore, revere, honor, whom they imitate, idolize, and form profound attachments to, whom they are willing to teach and from whom they are willing to learn, and whose respect, admiration, recognition, honor, reverence and love they desire… those are, overwhelmingly, other men. In their relations with women, what passes for respect is kindness, generosity or paternalism; what passes for honor is removal to the pedestal. From women they want devotion, service and sex. Heterosexual male culture is homoerotic; it is man-loving.”

Expand full comment
author

Whooooa! NAILED IT! What a perfect quote- thank you so much for sharing! 👏👏👏

Expand full comment

I was born in the 60’s so I’m definitely not new to this concept and I’ve fallen victim to being disregarded by men more often than I care to remember. I’ve never really thought about it in the context of Men that like women and men that don’t, but it makes perfect sense. I’ve seen women gain more rights, higher wages and higher paying jobs. Now the powers that be are trying to push us back because of toxic masculinity and rampant male insecurity. New mothers take heed and raise your sons to realize that tears are not a sign of weakness but a natural empowering aspect of being human.

Expand full comment
Sep 11Liked by Celeste Davis

I agree - also we need to start putting the raising of good men on MEN'S shoulders, not just women. Mothers carry enough already.

Expand full comment

Well said.

Expand full comment

Here here!….

Expand full comment

Trust me, without the tears or the readiness to shed it, men will actually be even less compassionate towards women as they are definitely less so with other men. Tears is a powerful and complementary evolutionary mechanism that triggers the protective and sympathetic feelings in men towards women. It's why men don't act protectively or sympathetically towards other men. Remove the capacity of a woman to be teary and you dull the feelings of men towards them even more.

Expand full comment
Aug 26Liked by Celeste Davis

Absolutely. I’ve noticed this for years, but not as completely nor as articulately as you have.

I worked in a graduate program for many years. Next to my office was a doctoral student who was short, balding, and not built like a jock. And yet, he constantly had women (other graduate students, from our program and from others) coming by to chat, set up coffee “dates”, plans to get pizza, etc. Many of the other, mostly male, students would ask me how this guy was attending all the women? I had observed this for several months and answered “He really *likes* women.” “Well, I like women!” “Do you spend any time with women other than working on a project or trying to score?” “Umm, I’m really too busy for that…”. I forbore from pointing out the time I could see them spending with other guys, and the remarks I’d heard about “how lucky so-and-so was: he didn’t have any women on his work team for X class.”

Expand full comment

heavy article to contemplate

Heavy comment about straight men reserving “love” for the men they respect. I can say, that’s a curious thing.

Had some male friends I considered friends, broke my hip at a skatepark and over the year plus recovery with two surgeries not one male friend showed up. My wife’s friends showed up; for her, knowing I was broken. No men.

Then while I was recovering I read The New Fatherhood’s article on Male Friendship Recession. That hit the soul.

https://www.thenewfatherhood.org/p/the-male-friendship-recession

Guess I picked the wrong dudes to try and be close friends with. They are higher up in careers than I.

Expand full comment

So sorry about your friends not showing up - that must sting.

Expand full comment

A bit; initially a lot.

Expand full comment

Oh this is a jaw drop moment for me. How perfectly it describes things. And how sad that it does.

Expand full comment

Do you feel you took a lot of male relationship burdens on your shoulders that you weren’t responsible for?

Expand full comment

Also worth saying that many women reward men for bad behaviour. So until we universally put our collective feet down and say it’s not good enough than there’s not much incentive for men to change.

Expand full comment

Sadly deficient in reason

Women in general are quite likable

In general

We should treat everyone with respect and want good for them

It is true it is easier to like women who act like women

Than to like men who act like women

In both cases like is not the key

The key is to want good and pursue good for everyone regardless of liking them.

Like is a feeling and feelings are an unreliable way to build and judge relationships.

And

If you want good for anyone you should be willing to have the discipline to listen and engage with them. To put them in a box makes it impossible to find the good for or in anyone.

Suck up your uncomfortable feelings and choose the good as your compass.

Expand full comment

It sounds to me like you are quoting a doctrine that in general I would agree with, but I must point out that, were you engaging in real dialogue, opening with “sadly deficient in reason” (on the author’s front porch, no less) would convince me that you were not so much examining the question as defending yourself. I fear you are proving her point. Tone deaf, at the very least.

Expand full comment

What on earth was that word salad needed for? Just say you dislike women.

Expand full comment

Women are likable, but men who act like women are unlikeable? Huh? Then you say not to put people in boxes.

None of that makes any sense.

Expand full comment
RemovedAug 30·edited Aug 30
Comment removed
Expand full comment

I suspect you have been hurt somewhere along the line. So I’ll move on and not let your comments occupy any more of my time.

Expand full comment
Removed (Banned)Aug 30·edited Aug 30
Expand full comment

Your dislike of women is plain to see. If a man is incapable of asking a woman at work "would you like to meet for a coffee sometime?" without it sounding like an assault, that is not the woman's fault.

Expand full comment
RemovedAug 30
Comment removed
Expand full comment

And by extension, that man-loving-ness of het male culture becomes narcissism. No one worships a (het male) hero like a man. Patriarchal religions took root and have endured because of this.

I can vouch for this as someone who lived and worked in high-end restaurants in NYC for many years. Eating and drinking and spending money in public to do this gives you a lot of insight into people in general. I was especially fascinated in a highway-crash-witness way with male-only tables, and how utterly homosexualized much of the interaction was, from ordering the wines with the highest scores and prices, the choicest cuts of meat, and so on. Easy and a bit obvious, perhaps, but if I had a twenty for every time a guy said, "What are you, a girl?" when another male ordered a drink that didn't perform as a male choice, I might have doubled my tips. More finely, the longer the dinners went on, the more I realized that these men were not in a hurry to leave, get home, go on to more diversified company; they were too content rutting around in a white linen-and-fine-china-plated capitalist homosexual orgy where everyone treated them like the "studs" they thought themselves and only wanted to be with each other.

Expand full comment

That's brilliantly-put.

I'll leave it to the women in my life to say whether I like women, based on my behaviour. But I can say that one of the first things I noticed coming into adolescence was how many boys actively disliked girls, even as they desired them. In grade 6 I played "elastics" (they had this enormous rubber band they'd stretch between two kids while others did jumps in and out, twisting in and around) with the girls, and the boys started calling me a "poofter". Meanwhile they were playing football and regularly embracing other boys... even at 11 years old I knew this was weird.

Expand full comment

When I came across this quote, it changed my life. I'm not kidding. It felt like my world just crumbled and I needed to rebuild, because everything about that quote makes so much sense!

Expand full comment

Yes! I have often wondered about this.

Expand full comment

Well said. I would also add the actual closet cases in Hollywood. Look no further than the roster of Scientologists. It's an open secret in Hollywood.

Expand full comment

I feel I have been hit by a ton of bricks filled with truths I have been avoiding for my entire life. My wall of self protection is in pieces and I need to face the facts I have been allowing the men in my life too much forgiveness for behaviors I suddenly understand in a new light. Thank you.

Expand full comment

“…from whom they are willing to learn…”

Wow, never figured it out before but that is it.

Expand full comment

Thank you! I’ve been looking for this quote for weeks and couldn’t lay hands on it 🙏🏼

Expand full comment

Wow, this is an AMAZING quote.

Expand full comment

Yeah. This.

Expand full comment
Aug 25Liked by Celeste Davis

Also, women get social capital and success by not liking women as well. Like being a guys girl gets you in good with the guys. Tolerating sexist remarks, laughing at horrible jokes, etc. But it only works for so long and it won’t protect you ultimately.

Expand full comment
author

Yes! Such a great point!

Expand full comment
Aug 26Liked by Celeste Davis

Yes! This was my thought too! Men don’t suffer consequences for disliking women and women gain favor for disliking women. It’s awful. I started understanding this two years ago when my youngest daughter was starting puberty and hating herself for it. It didn’t take long in our first conversation for me to see why. It wasn’t cool to like women and becoming one was terrifying for her. I have tried to be more vocal in my support for women ever since. I don’t want social clout for hating women. We are actively teaching our kids that women are awesome, we respect and support them!

Expand full comment

Not true at all. Here's another perspective: nobody hates women like other women. All the social capital and etiquette garb worn by women is to protect reputation in front of other women. All the tomboy's in my life tell me about the nightmarish gossip and cruelty other women spray on them. You think a man cares about you holding a Prada or a jute bag? No, but other women do.

Expand full comment

Yes, women can be vicious to each other. But like in all areas of life, we get to choose. I choose people to be in my life who care about what really matters. My female friends don't care if I have a handbag or just carry my phone and keys in my pockets.

Expand full comment

Women may put other women down for their choices, but at least they acknowledge their existence as more than a living piece of furniture.

Expand full comment

THIS is such an important point. I was trying to think of the reverse of Celeste’s point. Like if women have to like men to be revered/regarded well in society, and I’d argue the answer is yes, to be liked by both men and women, women must seem like the like/respect men. If women come off like they don’t like men, many men will automatically disregard them as being a male hater and go on the defense. She doesn’t like me so why would I like her?

Expand full comment
author

GREAT point Halle

Expand full comment

Miserable cat ladies, for instance, which says more about JD Vance than about women.

Expand full comment

exactly this. 'acting' in the workplace can mess up at home behaviour.

Expand full comment
Aug 28Liked by Celeste Davis

There are a lot of women who don't recognize misogyny when they see it.

Expand full comment
Removed (Banned)Sep 3
Expand full comment

No, not necessarily.

Expand full comment

OMG. How true?!! I thought I was the only woman who noticed this problematic issue.

An angry, belligerent reichwing lawyer in the late 70s, Phyllis Schlafly, rallied CONservatives and all media to magnify her protest against passing The Equal Rights Amendment for WOMEN.

She succeeded in blowing it up.

Expand full comment

As I was reading I was also thinking of WOMEN who don’t like women 😪

Expand full comment

Ugh so true on all counts

Expand full comment

Works well if you tend bar.

Expand full comment

So true!

Expand full comment
Aug 25Liked by Celeste Davis

I’ve been thinking about this exact topic a lot lately. My soon-to-be-ex husband does not like women. It’s crazy how in such a complicated, nuanced world, this particular measure of human nature is so stark, a “yes” or “no” with few caveats. When mentally surveying the men in my life, my intuition gives me the answer almost immediately. From a practical standpoint, as I re-enter singledom after a 20 year hiatus, this will be criterion numero uno when sizing up a potential date or lover. (As in yes, must like women).

Expand full comment
author

Yesss! Right?! I have the same experience- like it’s so obvious to me. Good luck out there Meg!! ❤️❤️❤️❤️

Expand full comment
Aug 26Liked by Celeste Davis

Yes, yes!! One of the biggest green flags I clocked when dating my husband was that he had multiple platonic friendships with both straight and gay women, even while working in a male-dominated field.

Good luck out there!

Expand full comment
Aug 27·edited Aug 27

Caroline, to your point about your husband working in a male-dominated field: my (ex) husband works in a creative field with many women colleagues. Meanwhile, one of the most “women-liking” guys I know by far, my friend’s husband, is a men’s college basketball coach (and I'll add comes from a family with very traditional gender roles).

I’m not sure how to articulate this, but it’s almost like a man’s for predilection for women (in this sense) is this intrinsic, almost spiritual part of their nature that transcends profession, interests, upbringing, etc. , at least in some instances. (But I'm also also not saying that men/people can't change. But to start, they have to want to. . . )

Expand full comment

They will only want to change when there are social and status demerits for disliking and disrespecting women.

Expand full comment

Who will assign those demerits?

Expand full comment

Big Ben Roethlisberger raped a woman. No consequence, right? Kobe Bryant, raped a woman. No consequence, right? Cuz these boys were he-men on the field and court and, godammit sports is IMPORTANT! So many others. What's your take?

Expand full comment

Make em pay! I say!

Expand full comment

Yes, it's a part of their character!

Expand full comment

lol, yes, that’s a better way of putting it! But when we generally (ie as a society) talk a man’s character in relation to how he treats/relates to women, I don’t think what we’re discussing here is really considered. But it should be!

Expand full comment

Yes, I think that being a generally respectful, polite person is how society sees it. Or, sometimes the standard is even lower, and society judges a person not being violent as good enough to be considered of good character. Is that what you mean?

Expand full comment

Powerful piece. This totally captures how you know: "It’s in the listening, the curiosity, the respect. It’s in the eye contact. It’s how they speak of other women or speak over women. It’s whether or not they ever read women authors, listen to podcasts hosted by women." And yes, so much about performing dominance until you don't know you're performing it anymore.

Expand full comment
author

“So much about performing dominance that you don’t know you’re performing it anymore” 👏👏 nailed it

Expand full comment

That's why you never ever sell your house and move state to be with your internet lover! No eye contact!!!!!

Expand full comment

Oof! No eye contact but you have no idea til the house is gone…

Expand full comment

Well, I should have had an idea, because I was only looking at a screen 👀!!

😅 ahhh, you live and learn!

Expand full comment
Sep 7·edited Sep 7

Take his house. That will teach him! Perfect.

Expand full comment
Aug 26Liked by Celeste Davis

Sort of related... Plenty of kids movies/books/shows are coded "gender neutral" and feature a leading male character. I struggle to think of any that feature a leading female character. The fact that a story is "about a girl" automatically makes it "not for boys"

Expand full comment
author

YESSSSS!!!! I notice this all the time!! Every Disney movie- it’s either marketed as for everyone with a male protagonist or only for girls with a female protagonist. And on the rare occasion there is a female protagonist- she has to be super super not feminine (turning red, girl in Wreck it Ralph, etc) We simply do not expect boys to watch ANYTHING whiffing of girly

Expand full comment
Aug 27Liked by Celeste Davis

Omg Paw Patrol. It drives me right up the wall. Yet mention it to others mothers and they don’t see it. Then realize you can’t belabour the point without coming off as weird, so you drop it and hope it sinks in later. Just maybe they will question why the lead is a little boy and the lead dog is male. Why 5/6 of the original dogs are male. Why the answer “so boys will watch it” is problematic. And how the only reason you know 1/6 is female is because she’s pink.

Expand full comment

That's why I prefer Bluey. She is a girl dog :-) Even though it sounds like a boy's name. Us Aussies are good at cheeky sneaky humour :-)

Expand full comment

Bluey is pure genius. Proof that writing tv for kids and adults and all genders that is good is completely possible!

Expand full comment

Indeed. My grandson loves the colour, the glitz, the glamour, the singing of the girly kids progs. I bought him two soft toys. Particular winged unicorns I knew he'd love. His father's face said all it needed to. So sad to be so blinkered.

Expand full comment

What I’m REALLY over is the national term “you guys.” Spare me—we’re not all guys!

Expand full comment
Aug 26Liked by Celeste Davis

Yes, and it even extends to fiction and film for adults!

Expand full comment
Aug 28·edited Aug 30Liked by Celeste Davis

The film industry caters to a young male audience, with its focus on comic book adaptations and superheroes, and action flicks with car chases and explosions - and a macho male starring in them.

Expand full comment

And the producer of those comic movies and superhero flicks is a woman. The entire book publishing industry is 98% female. The majority of pop stars are female. There are more rom-coms and drama movies made each year than action movies. Television is dominated by female-centred shows. Western culture has been female focused since the early 90s.

Expand full comment

So what?

Expand full comment

You and your fellow travellers are tilting at windmills. That's the point. But I don't expect anyone pointing this out will stop you from continuing to battle those imaginary foes, rationality and accountability are not virtues of the feminist.

Expand full comment

The ludicrous claim that modern culture caters to young males: Have you noticed who is the number one musical performer today? I'll give you a clue--she has a very macho boyfriend.

Expand full comment

Oh, gee whiz, one performer belies the fact that men have dominated the entertainment industry since the 1800s. You're a genius.

Expand full comment

Actually, not authentically macho. Read Tom Siebert today on Substack.

Expand full comment

Avatar: The Last Airbender and The Legend of Korra stand out as exceptions <3

Expand full comment

Korra l will give you but the main characters of Avatar are Aang, Sokka, Zuko, Airo (4 males) and Kotarra (1 female)... This is the standard paw patrol 4-1 gender "neutral" split exactly!

Expand full comment

Aang, Sokka, Zuko (3 males), Toph & Katara (2 females), plus Suki becomes a fairly big character later on (Sokka’s girlfriend). So, almost an even split for most of the story, and an even split for the rest. Not to mention that a trio of primary antagonists (Azula, Mai, and Ty Lee) are all female. So Avatar is actually a pretty even split.

Expand full comment
Aug 25Liked by Celeste Davis

Wonderful thoughts. As a man, I aspire to be like Glenn, and promise to check myself more often to avoid being like Tom.

Expand full comment
author

Thank you Hans 🙏🏼 that’s so refreshing

Expand full comment

Thank you. What Celeste Davis said.

Expand full comment

Good to hear you are willing to be open to seeing other perceptions and to doing things differently, Hans!

Expand full comment
Aug 26Liked by Celeste Davis

Reading this was a bit of a gut check for me as I have believed that I have genuinely liked women for the majority of my life. Now, on the other side of divorce with twin daughters and a young son, I hope I do better. Divorce from the patriarchy and church I hope brings a new and better horizon. Thank you for sharing this timely and much needed essay with all of us.

Expand full comment
Aug 27Liked by Celeste Davis

Here's my short list for spotting a man who likes women:

1) Has female friends.

2) Speaks positively about the contributions and skills of female colleagues. This is especially true if they're older women.

3) Will earnestly challenge a woman if he disagrees with her. This is not done in a domineering way, but the expectation that a woman can defend her ideas.

4) He will apologize to a women when he's in the wrong or has made a mistake.

5) He notices when women are being treated unfairly.

Expand full comment
author

👏👏👏great list!!

Expand full comment
Aug 26Liked by Celeste Davis

This prompted me to make a mental inventory of all the men I’ve known, and to consider the impact of culture — regional, ethnic and professional. By far the highest number of “men who like women,” I’ve found, are in the teaching profession. (Not all, but a plurality.) I wonder — does it attract men who are already comfortable functioning in what amounts to a matriarchy, and/or does it come over time through collaborating closely with so many women who are comfortable commanding a room (or a whole building) on the daily?

Expand full comment
Aug 27Liked by Celeste Davis

That might explain why VP Harris thought Tim Walz was the better partner.

Expand full comment

I had that thought too!

Expand full comment
Aug 26·edited Aug 31Liked by Celeste Davis

Celeste!!! Anne Helen Peterson's essay blew my mind, and now you've blown it again. I am so profoundly sad to read this and recognize some of my core experiences:

"They get to proudly wear that title of “good” man WHILE not respecting women, not listening to women, not liking women. Treating women like an equal is not a requirement for being a good man."

I remember talking to my parents as a 10- or 12-year-old, and explaining how one of my friends (a boy) was now incessantly teasing me, insulting me, and putting me down. I was upset at the verbal bullying, but since we had been good friend before, I also felt deeply betrayed. Their response was,

"No, he's a good kid."

It was then that I realized what you've said here: that if my family/community thought well of a boy or man, none of my experiences with him would affect that. This was confirmed over the years, but in no instance was it any less devastating.

Expand full comment

That reminds me of Jr High where the boys were following me and throwing apple cores, cookies and trying to trip me. My Mother explained that it was a sign that they liked me. I insisted that they hated me. I had read about the Witch Trials and felt like I was being pelted by refuse by the fearful men. I was right. She was wrong. A large segment of the male population do not like women.

Expand full comment

Right?? I still don't understand if people *actually think* that that's how kids express affection, or if it's just what people say to try to make victims feel better about themselves. Either way, it's totally messed up.

Expand full comment

Thank you so much for your comment. The particulars are different, but I definitely share that same experience of being deeply hurt and betrayed as a child. First by my "best friend's" bigotry and derogatory remarks. Second by my folks' utter dismissal of my reality.

Expand full comment

It’s disheartening and crazy making when our reality is dismissed or denied and has a long term impact on our/girls’ ability to trust our gut. And it’s incredibly confusing when innocent questions girls ask about the gender imbalance or erasure of women is responded to with “that’s just the way it is” or “it’s tradition.” That is why I wrote my Sexism & Sensibility — to put an end to the denial, and address gender bias and sexism directly with girls!!

Expand full comment

So sorry you experienced the same thing!

Expand full comment

Woah! This is so good! It explains why I tried to take on interests and attitudes that were masculine from when I was a teen. It feels a little harder for me to evaluate the men in my life because I work in a very male-dominated field and so I feel like I don’t have enough data: is he not reading women because he doesn’t like women or because there just aren’t many who’ve written in this subject? Does he not listen to women, or is it just me? When the whole system doesn’t like women, it’s hard to evaluate the individual men!

Expand full comment
author

Oh totally and when a lack of female representation is just the air you breathe- it’s so much harder for men to self evaluate or even notice if they treat women differently

Expand full comment
Aug 26Liked by Celeste Davis

Somewhat related to this it made me think about men in the church specifically. I tend to believe (and it seems like you’d agree) men are socialized to not like women. Are men who are raised in a patriarchal church at a disadvantage? From infancy basically in the Mormon church they only see men on the stand, men passing the sacrament, men as authority and worth listening to. Is it any wonder a man thought women’s talks in GC were for naps and snacks? It makes me so angry when I see men who leave the church but don’t even bother touching their internalized misogyny in their deconstruction.

Expand full comment

I think you nailed it, Celeste. The men who are not conscious of the way they’re treating women is only a mirror of our society as a whole, where most of us have our heads in the sand. I think the majority of us think that if they don’t see it, it’s not happening and they would rather dig themselves a hole and climb in, then be conscious, aware and self-empowered.

Expand full comment

I also work in a male-dominated field, and I think one of the realizations I have had recently is how many men are attracted to this field BECAUSE they don’t like women. The lack of women around them isn’t a drawback or a problem to be solved, it’s a perk. I know this isn’t everyone (I have also worked with men who like women, and it makes a huge difference), but I have found myself asking a lot fewer “is it just me?” questions recently, because no, it’s not just me. It’s much too common to be just me! Realizing this is both depressing and liberating, because I don’t have to keep trying so hard to make up for a problem I can’t fix.

Expand full comment
Aug 27Liked by Celeste Davis

Wow. First the article, then the comments. Revelation after revelation. I never thought of any of this. I just couldn’t manage working as a female engineer. I was miserable. I didn’t realize… I wasn’t liked. But it hangs together. Why women were let go so frequently. Why we and our close male friends always “under performed” no matter how well we did. Why no effort was made to combat the sexism. I understood it was sexism making my life hell at the end of my short career, but I never thought of it in terms of “like”. And as if the article wasn’t enough (and it was!), comments like yours have nailed it home personally. Wow.

Expand full comment

Yes! It sounds like you and I have had some similar experiences here. I am in my 8th year as a software engineer working in tech, and I’m just about ready to give up and move on. Until it became extremely obvious at my current job, I’m not sure I had words for why I kept facing all this subtle resistance that my male coworkers didn’t seem to run into. One of the experiences they cemented this for me was announcing my pregnancy/upcoming maternity leave to my team last month. My male teammates just stared at me and didn’t say anything about it, and then were like “okay… moving on!” It was extremely awkward, and when I talked to a friend about it, she was like “well clearly they just don’t like you! Someone who cared about your experience would have at least said congratulations!” MIND BLOWN MOMENT. It also explains these attitudes are so hard to do anything about, because what am I supposed to do about it? Go to the men up my management chain and tell them my coworkers don’t like me? I’m not sure they would even know what to do with that!

Expand full comment

Very similar! I’m sorry you are going through that. It is brutal and revelatory and validating and crushing all at once.

I couldn’t really believe I was actually being discriminated against (“subtle resistance” - damn so true - and impossible to explain in a way that gets taken seriously even by yourself!) until just days before I was called down to a meeting room and knew exactly what was happening.

I ran into my ex-boss and two ex-coworkers the other day and was puzzled that the ex-coworkers talked to me while my boss literally turned his back to me and ignored me. Surely he doesn’t feel guilty? Does he blame me? Do I make him uncomfortable? Oh. He doesn’t like me. And the other two genuinely do. That tracks.

You can’t make them like you. Even if it was possible to make a valid complaint, no amount of sensitivity training will make them like you. But you can get out before you cease to like yourself.

(Damn but it all makes sense now! Like why sensitivity training doesn’t work. Surely learning helps, but not if the real problem is dislike. Mind blown again!)

Expand full comment

“You can’t make them like you. Even if it was possible to make a valid complaint, no amount of sensitivity training will make them like you. But you can get out before you cease to like yourself.” 🔥🔥🔥

BRB, I’m going to put this on post-it note on my bathroom mirror.

Expand full comment
Aug 28Liked by Celeste Davis

Oh my I’m tearing up! But it feels so real. 🤗

Expand full comment

I have followed this discussion between the two of you with such interest as the revelations unfold. How can one do anything with such subtle discrimination as that? It’s impossible. So you cope with working with a bunch of people who don’t like you or you leave and the environment never gets any easier. How can equality of opportunity ever come into being?

Expand full comment

Wow yes! This is quite specific, but I remember noticing when I was younger and in a Catholic setting that many of the priests or young men who aspired to be priests seemed to feel incredibly awkward around women, and wondering if that was the reason they chose the priesthood in the first place.

Expand full comment

Oh yes there is so much to say about this in religious communities as well. I grew up evangelical, and men in my church were specifically taught to only listen to other men. I suspect that many men were drawn to this church tradition because it freed them from the need to treat women as equals.

Expand full comment

That's a great point! "Oh, no wonder I feel uncomfortable treating women as equals, God never *meant* for me to do so!" How very convenient.

Expand full comment

"...it freed them from the need to treat women as equals."

Was there ever a need?

Expand full comment

That's a great point about the whole system.

Expand full comment
Aug 26Liked by Celeste Davis

Spot on! This was definitely a trait I was looking for in a spouse, but maybe couldn’t define so clearly. Thank god he does since we’ve had three daughters. And once we had those babies, we realized the church didn’t like woman. “And for those reasons, I’m out.” 😂

Expand full comment
author

Haha oh gosh the church does NOT like women! 😂

Expand full comment

Most Churches do not like women and the Bible was written by misogynist men who were eliminating the women Priestesses, Goddesses and even their God's wife from the Sumerian texts that they were plagiarizing. History is interesting as long as you realize that it was His Story.

Expand full comment

Reading your comment, I just realized that the church I grew up in, Christian Science, actually liked women. Sunday services felt like a very feminine atmosphere -- few men attended, and the ones who did would not be considered masculine by today's standards. Maybe that's one reason (besides the whole doctor thing) CS has been vilified. I quit the church at 16 when I stopped believing the doctrine, but it was good to grow up feeling that being female was valued, at least on Sundays.

Expand full comment

Also, since patriarchy doesn’t work on Earth, why would we believe in three male spirits running Heaven?

Expand full comment

I started reading and stopped breathing somewhere along the way because this is all so true. You burned the house down, Celeste. There are only a few men left standing. But you know what? Even if it doesn’t matter to them, I don’t have time for men who don’t like women. Or women who don’t like women. So let it all burn. Those of us who appreciate and respect women are having a better time. I’m sure of it.

Expand full comment
author

🔥LET IT ALL BURN!🔥 We shall dance on the ashes 💃🏻

Expand full comment

My kind of party!

Expand full comment

Yes, we who enjoy close women friends absolutely are blessed. I adore my women friends and I also love men. Is there a term for that kind of like ambidextrous? 😂

Expand full comment

Celeste, I really liked this post. As I man—a man who grew up in the U.S., a man who likes women—I see the things you say here as almost obviously true, and it makes me terribly sad to realize that women don’t know this already. But I’d like to add that the U.S. is a county with an especially macho culture, at least in part (look at the 30 million MAGA people). I left the U.S. for Europe many years ago, and while no society is perfect, I have always felt much freer to openly like women here. I hope and pray that the tide of culture will change one day in my native country.

Expand full comment
author

I notice a difference as well! It varies a lot country to country and culture to culture- but there is a tangible difference in every day interactions with men- depending on what country you are in.

Expand full comment

Yes, and of course, there are different cultures in a country the size of the USA. One of my most perplexing experiences growing up there, as the son of a very independent and admirable single mother, was being confronted with the misogyny that was so pervasive in the culture around me. Now I think that misogyny has gotten much weaker in some parts of the country and much stronger in others. Honestly, Trump and his people are pushing nothing so much as a campaign to denigrate and disempower women, and it saddens me that that message has garnered so much support.

Expand full comment

This isn't new to CONservatives, reichwing tribe, at all. I was brought up to atleast be cognizant of politics even if I didn't vote (shame on me.) I was in my late teens, then.

I noticed in the 70s, an obnoxious, aggressive CONservative, reichwing lawyer named Phyllis Schlafly, rallied all media with all of her party behind her to stop The Equal Rights Amendment FOR women.

“ ‘Father Knows Best’, mom-is-subservient,” messaging was the trademark of all Republicans, CONservatives then and it's the same today, but with their misogyny off the hook now because their cult leader is.

Expand full comment

I really appreciate what you said here Gregory. I'd be interested to hear more about your life in Portugal. I've lived in Italy on and off for many years.

Expand full comment

Thanks, Chandi! My new Substack, Living Elsewhere, will be launching in a few days, so please feel free to check it out and see my take on what it's like living on this side of the Pond. (I'll write a bit about Italy too, though I've lived there much less. I will definitely check out what you have to say about life there.)

Expand full comment
Aug 26Liked by Celeste Davis

Great article, Celeste. I like women! At least I hope I am doing all the things that men do that like women. Honestly I have always preferred the company of women over men. Seems like I can have deeper conversations with women and I just enjoy being around them over men. Your article serves as a good reminder to keep working on doing the things that men do that like women. Thank you.

Expand full comment
author

Steve the fact that you regularly read, support and thoughtfully comment on a feminist newsletter is a strong indicator that you are a women liker 😊😊🙌🙌

Expand full comment

How interesting, Steve! It seems that almost every single one of my male friends have confided in me that they feel closer with women and that guys don’t respect their sensitive side.

Expand full comment
Aug 26Liked by Celeste Davis

I will have to reflect more about whether or not the men in my life like women. But roughly 80% of the men I encountered at the grocery store today certainly don’t respect women. When I encountered men in the aisles, 8 out of the 10 expected me to move out of their way. I know this isn’t new, but it was especially apparent today. Gross.

Expand full comment
Aug 29Liked by Celeste Davis

I periodically run an experiment: I refuse to move out of the way of young boys and men. The look on their faces as I stop and wait for them to move around me is always interesting.

I do this with young boys and men so they don’t get comfortable with walking where they want. I’m a crone, dammit! Have some respect and move out of MY way.

Expand full comment

I do the same thing, except with all men, young or old. It’s a work in progress, but I’m being mindful of how often I defer to men as an automatic response. I’m 55 and I’m over kowtowing to men just because. It’s not dominance I seek. I’m tired of twisting myself into knots and making myself as small and invisible as possible - rejecting myself in the process - in the clearly unsuccessful attempt to be likable or not viewed as a b, particularly by men.

Expand full comment